Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mike Nowak's avatar

I couldn't agree with you more, Bob. A "War Over Bird Names"? That looks ridiculous in print. As you note, future generations won't give an owl's hoot over this unserious discussion. It has nothing to do with taxonomy and everything to do with current political grievances. Give it a rest, folks. Time to move on.

Expand full comment
Aaron Wolfson's avatar

Thanks for continuing to share your thoughts on this, Bob.

I understand the argument about not assuming "weakness" on the part of birders—that same argument has compelled me on other topics—but to me, on changing bird names, that's still beside the point. I really think it can be as simple as you laid out: there's no good reason for these names; descriptive names are more fun, anyway.

Of course, the reaction to the change won't ever be so simple, and that's why I really appreciate you continuing to talk about it.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts